How does a Twitter discussion compare to a BlackBoard Discussion? To an in-class discussion?
Twitter is one of the most simplistic
platforms groups can use when discussing about a topic. Since a tweet is
limited to 140 characters, it only allows for a discussion relevant to the
topic to occur. The character limit can also be a frustration when trying to
have a discussion because not all relevant information one wants to post can be
done under one tweet. Instead, they would have to tweet multiple times if they go
over the 140 character limit. Twitter only allows for simple discussions which
in my opinion is a major flaw.
Furthermore, a
Blackboard discussion is similar to a Twitter discussion, without the
character limit. Blackboard provides more technological features to help
groups with collaborations. It also encourages users to research and provide
reliable sources when having a discussion. A Blackboard discussion will
result in users providing the most refined answers. I believe Blackboard will
encourage the most educated answers.
Moreover, in-class discussions are
the most natural in that participants will use their prior knowledge on a topic
to answer. It can also be unreliable because answers are knowledge based rather
than research based. In-class discussions encourages participants to speak out
and voice their opinions. In-class discussions do create the most natural and
engaging environment because it requires the most attention. Discussing about a
controversial topic in-class vs. online will always differ. In-class discussion
provides a more intimate environment while an online discussion is more of a
washed down version.
Afterall, these three types of
discussion methods have their own advantages and disadvantages, but are great
tools to communicate with each other. Regardless of which method is used, they
all provide a unique method to communicate.
No comments:
Post a Comment